Skip to main content

Broken Encapsulation, how hacking is really just finding ways to play middle man to component systems.

The annual black hat and defcon conferences are well known events where hackers and crackers of all types of systems come together to demonstrate their latest "exploits". These range from ways to snoop data or voice off of open cell or wifi networks to ways to modify the function of various hardware systems. In this years Defcon conference a team of hackers introduced some exploits of the computer systems inside a modern automobile. You can see a video of some of their results here, the interesting thing about hacking though that goes beyond the FUD generation that the media seems intent on producing by publishing such stories is that they aren't really that surprising.

Engineering systems is about learning to cleverly use abstractions and functional encapsulation to built extremely complex systems. In object oriented programming the concepts of encapsulation are a fundamental aspect of good OO design principles and I've written extensively on these ideas in posts in the past. Exploitation in the physical realm of hardware systems is realized by breaking the encapsulation of the physical components of the system (in this case a car) and then introducing a middle man to modulate the system directly or remotely. When one sees them this way it really is no surprise that they are possible, in OO programming the encapsulation layers are hidden behind layers of code abstractions that never present themselves for manipulation by outside agents. In software only the interface presented to the end user affords the possibility of an input  vector for committing some exploit (for example cross site scripting and validation attacks) but these offer a very small attack surface and one that can be readily fixed by software engineers once discovered.

Hardware is a bit different, most of the components in your car or tv or computer are directly accessible by you simply with the aid of a screw driver in many cases, you can break through the layers of physical encapsulation that otherwise would mask the interfaces you are presented from your ability to change the deeper components that present the functions in those interfaces. So it is in this exploit where the hackers had to gain physical access to the various control computers in the car in order to hijack and modulate their inputs and outputs...this type of broken encapsulation affords an attack surface that is not fixed as it is in a software UI where access to chop down behind the interface is not provided outside of the functional buttons, fields, drop downs provided by the engineers.

The attack surface for physical devices can be expanded by third party access...the breaking of the contracts of encapsulation that enable component based systems of hardware to function creates vulnerabilities for modulation of the interaction of those components...this should make perfect sense and should not be seen as a flaw in the design of the systems. A car computer should not necessarily have to be more protected from external access than they currently are by the physical barriers of the car that keeps them hidden and to expect that car companies build them such that such systems are impervious to access can be done but will come quite literally at a higher cost.



Popular posts from this blog

Highly targeted Cpg vaccine immunotherapy for a range of cancer


This will surely go down as a seminal advance in cancer therapy. It reads like magic:

So this new approach looks for the specific proteins that are associated with a given tumors resistance to attack by the body's T cells, it then adjusts those T cells to be hyper sensitive to the specific oncogenic proteins targeted. These cells become essentially The Terminator​ T cells in the specific tumor AND have the multiplied effect of traveling along the immune pathway of spreading that the cancer many have metastasized. This is huge squared because it means you can essentially use targeting one tumor to identify and eliminate distal tumors that you many not even realize exist.

This allows the therapy for treating cancer to, for the first time; end the "wack a mole" problem that has frustrated traditional shot gun methods of treatment involving radiation and chemotherapy ...which by their nature unfortunately damage parts of the body that are not cancer laden but …

Engineers versus Programmers

I have found as more non formally trained people enter the coding space, the quality of code that results varies in an interesting way.

The formalities of learning to code in a structured course at University involve often strong focus on "correctness" and efficiency in the form of big O representations for the algorithms created.

Much less focus tends to be placed on what I'll call practical programming, which is the type of code that engineers (note I didn't use "programmers" on purpose) must learn to write.

Programmers are what Universities create, students that can take a defined development environment and within in write an algorithm for computing some sequence or traversing a tree or encoding and decoding a string. Efficiency and invariant rules are guiding development missions. Execution time for creating the solution is often a week or more depending on the professor and their style of teaching code and giving out problems. This type of coding is devo…

AgilEntity Architecture: Action Oriented Workflow

Permissions, fine grained versus management headache
The usual method for determining which users can perform a given function on a given object in a managed system, employs providing those Users with specific access rights via the use of permissions. Often these permissions are also able to be granted to collections called Groups, to which Users are added. The combination of Permissions and Groups provides the ability to provide as atomic a dissemination of rights across the User space as possible. However, this granularity comes at the price of reduced efficiency for managing the created permissions and more importantly the Groups that collect Users designated to perform sets of actions. Essentially the Groups serve as access control lists in many systems, which for the variable and often changing environment of business applications means a need to constantly update the ACL’s (groups) in order to add or remove individuals based on their ability to perform certain actions. Also, the…